Introducing…The Write Way…

I’ve decided to ask a question about once a week or so on readers and writers opinions on…well, reading and writing. This little nugget will be called “The Write Way…”

So my question this week is one  that I debate over. Me – I am not a fan of Steinbeck…especially the Grapes of Wrath. I will admit this proudly and happily. What is the reason you ask? Well, I will tell you…it’s the description. Mind-numbing, long, drawn-out description. Now, to each his own. But this begs the question….

In your opinion, What is the Write Way for [good] Description? Short and Sweet? Or Long and Wordy?

Read the Grapes of Wrath or I will put this cigarette out on your face.

No Comments
  • Reply

    Martha

    July 16, 2010 at 5:22 am

    Julia, I always go with Short and Sweet on the descriptions. Many a book I tried to start and couldn’t get through the first page because it was long drawn out descriptions. You always seem to have a grabber right up front that gets my attention. Very cool. Martha

  • Reply

    Chrissy

    July 17, 2010 at 11:04 pm

    I believe that there has to be a harmonious marriage between the two. As a writer, your job is not to bore readers to death with long, drawn-out descriptions (as I whole-heartedly agree with you that Steinbeck does just that). I think when writers do this, it sort of amputates a readers’ ability to use their imagination. On the flipside, you don’t want every single line to be short & sweet; otherwise, I think the writing becomes too blunt. So….conclusion: I feel that readers need to be given description in order to draw them in & point in the right direction-that is the perfect time to then shorten it up, leaving the rest to the readers’ imagination (which is what I feel your writing does ; ) That is how writing should be: it should make you think & interpret.

    • Reply

      Cat

      July 18, 2010 at 1:05 am

      I never even finished the Grapes of Wrath. I meant to, but my boyfriend was in the same class and was a slacker, so alas. Ultimately, the book SHOULD be descriptive to set the scene and the mood, but not so much so that it is a burden to finish (or carry around). Some really long books, I find I wish were longer, and some short stories seem too long.

      I guess it matters more about quality, than quantity.

  • Reply

    julesjustwrite

    July 23, 2010 at 2:24 am

    Thanks to all who answered “The Write Way” question!

    It’s interesting to see the various takes from readers and everyones own personal experiences.

    Overall, what probably matters is how good the description is at hooking you. Not how long or short…

Leave a Reply

Leave A Comment

Instagram

  • #tbt to that one time I met John Mayer and could show off my stomach in short shirts. #throwbackthursday #johnmayer #tbt❤️ #bellyshirt
  • Best. Concert. Ever.  @thedevilmakes3
  • The Devil Makes Three.  Kill me. ❤❤❤
  • Pre-concert beers. #thedevilmakesthree #beer
  • I am breathing deep and sharing the first line of my (currently) unpublished book - "The Ramblin' Hand of Sherry Anne." After rewriting 75% of my last draft in three months, edits are finally fucking finished and I feel calm and peaceful and light. Typically, I tend to not want to share for fear of failure BUT I am freaking psyched. No more white knuckling this novel. Here goes nothin'. #teasertuesday #amwriting #amediting #manuscript #writerlife #writer #writermama #novel #publishedorbust
  • Bukowski, bath and bubbles. Book #1 of #2017. #amreading #bookstagram #bookworm #bathtime #bukowski #booknerd #books #reading #read

Follow Me